So... is Demogorgon officially dead?
Savage Tide Ending... Canon? (spoilers)
Well, the Lich Queen is officially dead now because of a Dungeon adventure.
Which would mean ignoring canon. The PSCS stuff already says she's dead. I'm not asking whether I should stick to canon, or whether I should let him die or not. I'm asking if there's a canon stance on his "death" at the end of the adventure.
Ah, sorry.
Well, it says at the end of p. 96: "Even if the PCs manage the near-impossible and slay him on his home plane, the ex-Prince of Demons will not remain dead for long. Like Obox-ob and Orcus before him, it's only a matter of time before Demogorgon returns to the Abyss, whether grown from the shell of a surviving aspect, resurrected by a loyal and powerful minion, or even spontaneously reformed by the Abyss itself."
I guess he's "officially not dead for long" or something like that.
While we're on the subject of killing off extremely powerful beings...
Maanzecorian needs to be resurrected. :shock: <3
Because Maanzecorian is freaking awesome.
BoGr Guide to Missile Combat:
1) Equip a bow or crossbow.
2) Roll a natural 1 on d20.
3) ?????
4) Profit!
I do like Maanzecorian. I also like Dragon Magazine's suggestion that the mooncalves were created from Maanzecorian's corpse.
As for Demogorgon, it depends on what the outcome of the adventure is. It doesn't have an official ending. It could be that the PCs get the crap beaten out of them in first level and never make it to the Abyss, in which case Demogorgon's two heads may have merged, leaving him the King of the Abyss and a greater deity.
It's also possible the PCs succeed in thwarting the Savage Tide, but don't succeed in killing or dethroning Demogorgon.
Planewalker's staff decided to endorse the death of Vlaakith as "official" after much discussion, because they thought it made an interesting story. Vlaakith isn't officially dead in Wizards of the Coast products, however - she's still mentioned as very much alive as recently as the new villains book that came out last month.
I don't think Savage Tide will have any impact on official WotC stuff unless Erik Mona or James Jacobs end up writing any of it (James Jacobs is still writing Demonomicons, so it's possible). What Planewalker intends on doing is something to discuss in the forums, and is largely theoretical anyway unless someone intends on writing an adventure involving Demogorgon as an official Planewalker product.
Well, we are discussing it in the forums already (unless I am extremely lost), so let me add to the discussion. Since I haven't yet read the adventure being discussed, I'm not quite sure how the ending is described, but I do know the general gist from the Wikipedia article. If it is anything like previously published adventures, it probably goes along the lines of "if the PC's succeed, so and so happens, but maybe not / but not for long!". Usually such things assume that by canon the PC's reach the very end of the adventure and succeed to some degree, but the villain has the possibility of coming back. I would also note that the resurrecting of Orcus was similarly not established at the end of the adventure, but everybody seemed to accept it as eventually occurring. Seeing as how Demogorgon is such a major and popular guy, it is unlikely that he's gone for good, if at all. Whether anyone wants to have fun with the possibilities of the planes without one of the major demon lords is really up in the air. I really do think that Planewalker should vote on a stance on this issue, seeing as how it is highly planar in nature, as WotC has diverged far enough to be a non-influence on the ongoing Planescape canon.
I agree. I have no real opinions on most of the outcome (as I'm not terribly familiar with the adventure path), but I vote we keep Demogorgon. Hell, I vote that campaign settings without him gain Demogorgon, that's how cool he is.
Pants of the North!
Its a good thing only good things come to an end. Coz demogorgon shouldn' go anywhere! He ranks number one on the abyssal lords that I've waxed, and I still think he should remain. I mean he THE tanarri! What would the abyss do without him? probably lose a lot of self esteem.
Granted I've only ever fought and killed two abyssal lords. 1.Demogorgon and 2. Zuggtmoy and only one arch devil, Mephistopheles. But my point remain valid!
I also do not know adventure details, but his "death" would be mayor event and power shift in Abyss.
For example Dagon would claim entire layer wich he shared with Demogorgon.
Demogorgon´s fate after his "death"? Here is some of ideas:
1. He would defintly return in one shape or another, his minions and cultist would see to that, even Orcus (after he croaked for second time from last word) had to depend on litlle guys for his ressurection.
2. Without intrervention of mortal minions (or divine minions) considerable time should pass for his essence to recover and reform, 666 years prehaps.
3. His "death" is only rebirth into new form, wich should be apropriate since demons are beings of chaos: Demogorgon´s personalites have split into seperate bodies and finaly can folow their separate agendas and goals, or he returns without body at all but rather as formlless driving will of all demonkind, unseen pupeteer of countlles legions.
EDIT: Some one should put end to those epic adventure paths, they start as ok ideas, but eventualy true villan behind the plot (usualy some evil god or demon lord) is revealed and PC have to kill him. I mean they have offed Vlakith, Kyuss, and now Dmogorgon. Who is next? If they keep that way soon none of good old archvillans will remain.
SAVE THE ABYSSAL LORDS!!!
One-eyed, one-horned, flying, purple people eater says: "Monsters are nature's way for keeping XPs fresh."
Well the way I was thinking. Maybe just maybe an abyssal lord might try and redeem itself. What if, just what if that redeeming lord, was, ....
Demogorgon?
Why not? It is good idea as any other. He is chaotic and crazy enough to do it, and near death experience could change his dispositon toward life.
But who in the multiverse would belive him? "Hi, my name is Demogorgon and would you like me to help you across the street ´maam?" It would be fishy from the start, not to mention that other Abyssal Lords would want to put him out of his mysery.
Onother option is that he become true neutral power (near death has made diference between his personalities even more extreme),with one personlity LG and another CE that balance each other into true neutrality (something like demonic version of "Harvy Dent" (aka Two Face from Batman).
One-eyed, one-horned, flying, purple people eater says: "Monsters are nature's way for keeping XPs fresh."
But who in the multiverse would belive him? "Hi, my name is Demogorgon and would you like me to help you across the street ´maam?" It would be fishy from the start, not to mention that other Abyssal Lords would want to put him out of his mysery.
Onother option is that he become true neutral power (near death has made diference between his personalities even more extreme),with one personlity LG and another CE that balance each other into true neutrality (something like demonic version of "Harvy Dent" (aka Two Face from Batman).
That last bit's bloody brilliant.
I was also thinking of an idea that. Maybe there should be entities out there that have been to both extremes of the spectrum and have swung verry far multiple ways. So, an Abyssal lord becomes a high up celestial then falls into a arch devil and then becomes a high up beast lands thingy (Ugh my upper planar hierarchy is abysmal) then perhaps they all eventually end up remaining as incredibly powerful true neutral entities that prefer to remain that way?
The redeeming route is brilliant but works better if Demogorgon stays as one even more f-ed up multiple-identity entity and requires quite a bit of explanation as to how either side of the incredibly evil and insane abyssal lord would suddenly become Good. An possible alternative is the following trite but not necessarily bad (in terms of story and my opinion ) scenario. The Savage Tide doesn't go off as planned... unless of course it was planned as a distraction so that Demogorgon could split in half. After he does, both evil sides realize that they are better off together. Not because they miss each other, mind you, or that they see the error in their ways, but rather because Demogorgon is after all one entity and is much more powerful than even a sum of his parts. Thus, both halves realize that they stand no chance to acrue even part of the power of the original unless they rejoin before everything that they've worked for since the Obyrith war is turned to dust.
Eh, I usually view those kind of campaigns more as possibilities. Maybe it happened as presented, but the PCs failed at the end. Or Only slew a strong Avatar of Demogorgon. Or its all a load of crock. Given, I'm not that familiar with the campaign, but it's gonna take more than that for me to give up on my favorite abyssal lord.