Hey.
I have a question on which spells work in the planes and which do not (speaking of the 3.5 ed in my case).
Cure light wounds is stated in the PHB as "channeling positive energy", while enervation uses negative energy. Is this at all possible on the outer planes without a conduit to the inner and thus the positive and negative planes?
Thanks for your thoughts
Stoertebeker
It is possible according to the rules. As far as the mechanics of how it works in the cosmology- that's one I would generally consider under one of two planar theories:
A) Birth and death occur often enough amongst the mortal populations of the planes for there to *have* to be some sort of link to the Inner Planes to exist (this is one of the primary reasonings behind the existance of the Ordinal plane)
B) Many of these spells are granted by powers, and the powers can certainly open up temporary channels for the energy to pass through to the caster. For non-clerical casting - it may sap it's way through existing portals, or part of the casting itself is a opening pinprick sized gate to the required plane.
Usually the 'connection' rule is applied to transitive plane requirements, but I'm sure there's some other planar theorums that others here have on hand to explain this (or know what the canon answer is)